Decision no. 1160a/2016

On 12 March 1938, the property, which was connected to the ownership of a one quarter share of a courtyard plot and situated in the Jewish quarter of Mattersburg, was owned by the Jewish association J. T. E.

Following the Anschluss of Austria to the German Reich in 1938 the Liquidation Commissar competent for Austrian associations dissolved the association and transferred its property to the Municipality of Mattersburg. The municipality then acquired further properties from Jewish owners who had been forced to leave the town.

In 1960 the collection agencies, established in 1955 on the basis of the Staatsvertrag ("State Treaty"), entered into negotiations with the municipality and a residential cooperative that had acquired land from the municipality regarding the restitution of seized properties. In September 1961 a settlement was concluded by the parties, according to which the collection agencies waived their claims in exchange for a payment of 200,000 Schilling.

In the application for in rem restitution, the applicant before the Arbitration Panel asserted that the previous restitution settlement had constituted an "extreme injustice".

In its juridical appraisal, the Arbitration Panel first examined whether the requested properties were publicly-owned and rejected the applications referring to areas that had been privately owned on the cut off day 17 January 2001. On the cut off day, the Province of Burgenland and the Municipality of Mattersburg each owned a partial area of the requested properties.

When examining the settlement of 1961 it was not possible to determine a discrepancy in value between the value of the properties at the time of the settlement and the settlement amount. As there were no indications that the collection agencies’ freedom of contract had been limited in any way the settlement was not considered to be extremely unjust and the application for in rem restitution of the areas owned by the Province of Burgenland was also rejected.

The Municipality of Mattersburg acknowledged the claim to in rem restitution of the area under its ownership. However, in rem restitution was unfeasible since the area had changed hands after 17 January 2001. Following consultations with the parties to the proceedings and having obtained a valuation report by an independent expert on the areas in question the Arbitration Panel recommended the Municipality of Mattersburg to award the applicant a sum of 13,660 Euros.